The first ROH Caged Collision event was taped on January 31, 2009 and aired on April 17, 2009 on pay-per-view from the Frontier Fieldhouse in Chicago Ridge, IL.
- Triple Threat Match: Alex Payne def. Kenny King & Silas Young by rolling up Silas Young.
- Claudio Castagnoli def. Kevin Steen by pin following the Ricola Bomb.
- Jerry Lynn & The Necro Butcher def. Brodie Lee & Delirious (Age of the Fall) by Jerry Lynn pinning Delirious following the Cradle Piledriver.
- #1 Contender’s 4-Way Match: Tyler Black def. Jimmy Jacobs, Austin Aries, & Bryan Danielson by rolling up Jimmy Jacobs to become the #1 Contender for the ROH World Title.
- ROH World Championship: Nigel McGuinness (c) def. El Generico by submission to the London Dungeon to retain.
- Steel Cage Warfare: Roderick Strong, Brent Albright, Ace Steel, Erick Stevens, & Jay Bricoe def. Adam Pearce, Tank Toland, Davey Richards, Eddie Edwards, & Bobby Dempsey (Sweet N’ Sour, Inc.) by Brent Albright pinning Adam Pearce following the Half Nelson Suplex.
- Steel Cage Warfare
- ROH World Championship
- #1 Contender’s 4-Way Match
- Jerry Lynn & The Necro Butcher Vs. Brodie Lee & Delirious
- Triple Threat Match
- Claudio Castagnoli Vs. Kevin Steen