The 11th edition of WWE Judgment Day came to you, live on pay-per-view, from the Allstate Arena in Chicago, IL.
- Umaga def. CM Punk (in his hometown) by pin following the Samoan Spike.
- ECW Championship: Christian (c) def. Jack Swagger by roll-up with the tights to retain.
- John Morrison def. Shelton Benjamin (with Charlie Haas) by pin following Starship Pain.
- Intercontinental Championship: Rey Mysterio (c) def. Chris Jericho by pin following the 619NS.
- WWE Championship: Batista def. Randy Orton (c) by DQ after Randy Orton slapped the referee; Randy Orton (c) retains.
- John Cena def. Big Show by pin following the Attitude Adjustment.
- World Heavyweight Championship: Edge (c) (with Matt Hardy) def. Jeff Hardy by pin following a Super Edgecution to retain.
- World Heavyweight Championship
- Intercontinental Championship
- John Morrison Vs. Shelton Benjamin
- ECW Championship
- Umaga Vs. CM Punk
- WWE Championship
- John Cena Vs. Big Show
After the WWE Title Match, Cody Rhodes & Ted DiBiase came into the ring and all three members of Legacy assaulted Batista. However, Ric Flair made the save and Batista & Flair ended up clearing the ring of Legacy.
Early in the night, World Heavyweight Champion Edge (from SmackDown) went into the office of his wife and RAW General Manager Vickie Guerrero. During the World Heavyweight Title Match, Matt Hardy (from RAW) appeared and hit Jeff Hardy with the cast, which ended up costing Jeff the title.
The Miz also made an appearance at Judgment Day and called out Chicago Cubs outfielder Alfonso Soriano as a "Cena surrogate". After Soriano did not come into the ring, Miz declared himself 4-0 against John Cena. Santino Marella then came out and stood up for Soriano, calling him a "fellow Italian". Santino & Miz ended up brawling in the ring before Miz hit Santino with a DDT. After being called an "embarassment" by Edge earlier on, Chavo Guerrero came out and hit Santino with the Frog Splash.